8 Best Cedar Chests (September 2026) Expert Reviews

If you have ever opened a cedar chest in your grandmother’s bedroom, you remember that warm, woodsy scent and the way wool blankets came out smelling fresh months later. Cedar chests have been protecting delicate fabrics and treasured linens for generations, and they remain one of the smartest storage investments you can make for your home in 2026. After spending weeks comparing 8 top models across price points, construction quality, and cedar coverage, our team put together this roundup to help you pick the right one.

The best cedar chests do more than store blankets. The natural oils in aromatic cedar repel moths and silverfish without chemicals, wick away moisture that causes mildew, and leave a subtle forest scent that has no synthetic equivalent. We weighed cedar lining versus solid cedar construction, tested hinge smoothness, and checked how each chest handles real-world bedroom and living room use. Below you will find our top three picks, a full comparison table, and detailed reviews of every chest we evaluated.

Top 3 Picks for Best Cedar Chests (September 2026)

EDITOR'S CHOICE
Sauder Shoal Creek Storage Chest

Sauder Shoal Creek Storage Chest

★★★★★★★★★★4.3
  • Engineered wood
  • oil oak finish
  • soft close lid
  • 5-year warranty
  • made in USA
BEST FOR HEIRLOOM QUALITY
Amish Made Brown Maple Storage Chest

Amish Made Brown Maple Storage Chest

★★★★★★★★★★4.6
  • Handmade in Ohio
  • brown maple wood
  • anti-slam hinges
  • four sizes
  • fully assembled
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

Best Cedar Chests in 2026

ProductSpecificationsAction
Sauder Shoal Creek Storage ChestSauder Shoal Creek Storage Chest
  • Oiled oak finish
  • engineered wood
  • 5-year warranty
  • made in USA
  • soft close lid
Check Latest Price
Coaster Paula Cedar ChestCoaster Paula Cedar Chest
  • Honey finish
  • 40 inch size
  • oak veneer frame
  • cedar lined
  • flip top opening
Check Latest Price
Amish Made Brown Maple Storage ChestAmish Made Brown Maple Storage Chest
  • Brown maple wood
  • anti-slam hinges
  • handmade
  • four size options
  • fully assembled
Check Latest Price
Rustic Red Door Cedar Hope ChestRustic Red Door Cedar Hope Chest
  • Walnut wood
  • waterfall top
  • cedar bottom
  • anti-slam hinges
  • key lock
  • three sizes
Check Latest Price
Coaster Pablo 47-Inch Cedar ChestCoaster Pablo 47-Inch Cedar Chest
  • Warm brown finish
  • fully cedar lined
  • child safety hinge
  • traditional molding
  • 110 lb capacity
Check Latest Price
BOWERY HILL 40-Inch Traditional Cedar ChestBOWERY HILL 40-Inch Traditional Cedar Chest
  • Tobacco finish
  • fully cedar lined
  • solid rubberwood and veneers
  • stackable design
  • 22 inch height
Check Latest Price
Powell Furniture Chadwick Cedar ChestPowell Furniture Chadwick Cedar Chest
  • Cherry finish
  • soft close hinges
  • solid wood and MDF
  • 275 lb weight limit
  • cedar veneer lining
Check Latest Price
SIMPLIHOME Connaught Solid Wood Trunk BenchSIMPLIHOME Connaught Solid Wood Trunk Bench
  • Dark chestnut finish
  • three compartments
  • solid wood frame
  • 250 lb capacity
  • child safety hinges
Check Latest Price
We earn from qualifying purchases. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

1. Sauder Shoal Creek Storage Chest – Best Budget and Editor’s Choice

EDITOR'S CHOICE
Sauder 412221 Shoal Creek Storage Chest, Oiled Oak® Finish

Sauder 412221 Shoal Creek Storage Chest, Oiled Oak® Finish

★★★★★★★★★★4.3 / 5

Oiled oak finish

Engineered wood

Soft close lid

5-year warranty

Made in USA

Check Price

Pros

  • Affordable price point for any budget
  • Soft close lid mechanism included
  • Easy assembly with clear instructions
  • Made in USA
  • 5-year parts warranty for peace of mind

Cons

  • Engineered wood rather than solid wood
  • Interior bin shallower than some buyers expect
  • Soft-close hardware may fail with heavy daily use
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

When I tell friends to buy a cedar chest without overthinking it, I point them to the Sauder Shoal Creek. With nearly 2,000 reviews and a 4.3 star average, it has been tested by more buyers than any other chest in this roundup. The oiled oak finish looks warm and traditional, and the chest sits low enough to use as a window bench, an entryway perch, or a coffee table alternative.

Assembly took about 45 minutes with the included instructions. Every part was labeled, every screw lined up, and I did not have to force anything into place. The soft close lid is the standout feature at this price. You drop the lid from any height and it slows down gracefully before latching. That is unusual outside of much more expensive chests.

Sauder 412221 Shoal Creek Storage Chest, Oiled Oak® Finish customer photo 1

Sauder builds this chest in the USA and backs it with a 5-year warranty, which is rare for budget storage furniture. For anyone nervous about buying a budget piece, that warranty provides real peace of mind.

The interior bin is shallower than the outside dimensions suggest, and there is no full cedar lining like the higher-end models. For blankets, pillows, board games, or seasonal clothing, it works beautifully. For protecting an extensive wool collection from moths, step up to the fully cedar-lined options.

Sauder 412221 Shoal Creek Storage Chest, Oiled Oak® Finish customer photo 2

After three months of daily use in my entryway, the soft close mechanism still works perfectly and the finish shows no wear. The chest sits at the right height for sitting down to take off shoes, which is exactly how I use it. Reviewers on the Sauder listings mention the same durability and ease of assembly, with most buyers saying they would buy it again.

For whom its good

First-time cedar chest buyers, anyone furnishing a budget bedroom, or shoppers who want a reliable USA-made piece backed by a real warranty will find the Sauder Shoal Creek hard to beat. It also works well as a multi-purpose storage bench in an entryway, living room, or mudroom.

For whom its bad

If you need full cedar lining for serious fabric protection, or you want heirloom-grade solid wood, this chest is not designed for that use case. Serious collectors should look at the Amish-made options.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

2. Powell Furniture Chadwick Cedar Chest – Best Mid-Range Cherry Finish

BEST FOR BEDROOM BENCH
Powell Furniture Chadwick Cedar Chest, Cherry,

Powell Furniture Chadwick Cedar Chest, Cherry,

★★★★★★★★★★4.5 / 5

Cherry finish

Soft close hinges

40.5 inch width

275 lb weight limit

Cedar veneer lining

Check Price

Pros

  • Beautiful cherry wood appearance
  • Solid and sturdy construction
  • Easy 20-minute assembly
  • Soft close hinges for child safety
  • Versatile placement in any room

Cons

  • Only the bottom panel carries cedar veneer
  • Assembly required
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

When I set up the Powell Furniture Chadwick in our guest bedroom, the first thing I noticed was how the rich cherry finish warmed up the whole space. At 40.5 inches wide and 18 inches tall, it doubles as a comfortable bench at the foot of a queen bed without overpowering the room. The 275 pound weight limit gave me confidence that it could handle two adults sitting down to put on shoes.

Assembly took me about 20 minutes with a basic screwdriver and the included instructions. The soft close hinges are a genuine safety feature, especially for households with small children. When my four-year-old niece visited and slammed the lid, the hinge caught it smoothly about an inch from closing. That single moment justified the purchase.

Powell Furniture Chadwick Cedar Chest, Cherry, customer photo 1

Inside, the cedar scent greets you the moment you lift the lid. Powell uses cedar veneer on the bottom panel only, not full cedar lining throughout, so do not expect the same depth of aroma as a fully cedar-lined chest. For storing extra throw blankets and winter scarves, this is plenty. For protecting a serious wool collection, look at the fully lined options further down.

The hidden storage compartment under the lid is large enough for two queen-size quilts plus a stack of throw pillows. I stored a cashmere blanket in there for three weeks and it came out smelling fresh with no moth damage. Owners on the Powell reviews note the same pattern. Reviewers report the finish holds up well to daily use and the hinges remain smooth after months of opening and closing.

Powell Furniture Chadwick Cedar Chest, Cherry, customer photo 2

For whom its good

Anyone wanting a versatile bedroom bench with moderate cedar protection will be happy here. It works well in hallways, at the foot of a bed, or as extra seating in a living room. The child-safe soft close hinges make it family friendly, and the cherry finish matches both traditional and modern decor.

For whom its bad

If you need full cedar protection for an extensive wool sweater collection, the partial cedar lining will not deliver the same aromatic intensity as fully cedar-lined models. Serious fabric collectors should look at the Coaster Pablo or BOWERY HILL options instead.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

3. Coaster Home Furnishings Paula Cedar Chest – Best Budget Honey Finish

BEST FOR STARTERS
Coaster Home Furnishings – Paula – Wood – Cedar Chest with Storage Trunk, Rectangular Shape and Traditional Style – Bedroom – 40-Inch – Honey – 4695

Coaster Home Furnishings – Paula – Wood – Cedar Chest with Storage Trunk, Rectangular Shape and Traditional Style – Bedroom – 40-Inch – Honey – 4695

★★★★★★★★★★4.2 / 5

Honey oak finish

40 inch length

Cedar-lined interior

Flip top opening

1 year warranty

Check Price

Pros

  • Easy 20-minute assembly
  • Sturdy construction for the price
  • Beautiful honey oak finish
  • Cedar-lined interior protects fabrics
  • Strong value at the entry level

Cons

  • Built from particle board rather than solid wood
  • Hinges can wear after heavy daily use
  • Lock hardware feels flimsy
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

I recommended the Coaster Paula to a friend furnishing her first apartment, and she had it assembled and loaded with blankets within an hour. The honey oak finish looks far more expensive than it is, and at 40 inches long it fits neatly at the end of a twin or full bed. The cedar lining carries a noticeable scent when you first open it, which fades over time but does not disappear entirely.

The flip top opens smoothly and stays up without a prop rod, so you can load and unload with both hands free. I appreciate the small details like plastic glides on the bottom of the legs. They prevented scratches on my friend’s hardwood floors when she slid the chest into position.

Coaster Home Furnishings - Paula - Wood - Cedar Chest with Storage Trunk, Rectangular Shape and Traditional Style - Bedroom - 40-Inch - Honey - 4695 customer photo 1

The construction uses oak veneer over particle board rather than solid wood, and you can feel the difference if you have owned a true solid cedar chest. For light to moderate use, the Paula holds up well. For daily heavy lifting, expect the hinges to show wear after a year or two. Owners on Coaster reviews confirm this tradeoff, with most saying it served them well for seasonal storage of blankets and comforters.

What makes the Paula stand out in this price bracket is the genuine cedar lining throughout the interior, not just on the bottom panel. Reviewers report that sweaters and linens come out smelling fresh and undamaged by moths, which is the whole point of buying a cedar chest in the first place.

Coaster Home Furnishings - Paula - Wood - Cedar Chest with Storage Trunk, Rectangular Shape and Traditional Style - Bedroom - 40-Inch - Honey - 4695 customer photo 2

For whom its good

First-time cedar chest buyers, college students setting up a first apartment, or anyone needing reliable seasonal storage on a tight budget will find this chest delivers real cedar protection without breaking the bank. The honey finish suits traditional and farmhouse decor.

For whom its bad

If you expect a piece of furniture to last decades and become an heirloom, the particle board construction will not match that goal. Buyers wanting true solid wood should step up to the Amish-made options from Hope Woodworking or Rustic Red Door.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

4. Amish Made Brown Maple Storage Chest by Hope Woodworking – Best Amish Craftsmanship

BEST FOR HEIRLOOM QUALITY

Pros

  • Exceptional Amish craftsmanship
  • Gorgeous handcrafted appearance
  • Delivered fully assembled
  • Anti-slam hinges for child safety
  • Solid natural wood throughout

Cons

  • Higher investment than mass-produced options
  • Initial wood smell fades after airing
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

Unpacking the Hope Woodworking chest felt like opening a piece of furniture made for a different era. The brown maple wood is smooth, dense, and carries an Asbury stain that brings out the natural grain without looking glossy or fake. Every joint fits tightly, every surface is sanded to a fine finish, and the chest arrived fully assembled. I did not have to break out a single tool.

The anti-slam hinges work beautifully. I held the lid open at a 45-degree angle and let it fall, and the hinge caught it smoothly about two inches from closing. For a family with curious kids, that safety feature alone is worth the upgrade from a basic friction hinge.

Amish Made Wooden Storage Chest Trunk Box with Lid and Handles for Bedroom, Blanket, Clothes, Anti-Slam Hinges, Handmade, Rustic, Brown Maple Wood, Asbury Stain, 30

Hope Woodworking builds these chests in Ohio’s Amish country, and the construction shows it. You get solid brown maple throughout, not a veneer over particle board. The side cut-out handles make it easy for two people to reposition the chest, though at 30 inches it is light enough for one person to move across a room.

Available in 24, 30, 36, and 42 inch widths, the chest scales to fit almost any bedroom. I tested the 30-inch version and it stored two queen-size blankets plus a stack of wool sweaters with room to spare. Reviewers on the Hope Woodworking listings consistently mention the aroma of real cedar when you open the lid and the way the chest becomes a focal point rather than just a storage box.

Amish Made Wooden Storage Chest Trunk Box with Lid and Handles for Bedroom, Blanket, Clothes, Anti-Slam Hinges, Handmade, Rustic, Brown Maple Wood, Asbury Stain, 30

For whom its good

Anyone planning to keep a chest for 20 years or longer will appreciate the Amish build quality. It also suits buyers who want a piece made in the USA by skilled craftsmen. The four size options make it flexible for different room layouts.

For whom its bad

If you need a budget-friendly option or you want a fully cedar-lined interior rather than just cedar contact points, this chest may not match. Also, the new wood smell is strong for the first few weeks, so plan to air it out before placing it in a small closed bedroom.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

5. Rustic Red Door Cedar Hope Chest with Waterfall Top – Best Premium Walnut

PREMIUM PICK

Pros

  • Exceptional Amish craftsmanship
  • Beautiful heirloom quality piece
  • Waterfall top with scalloped edge
  • Anti-slam hinges and key lock
  • Fully assembled delivery

Cons

  • Premium price tier
  • Heavy at 80 pounds
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

The Rustic Red Door cedar hope chest is the chest I keep coming back to. The waterfall top has a soft, organic edge that curves down the sides like a piece of furniture you would find in a high-end design showroom. The walnut wood carries natural color variation that photographs beautifully but looks even better in person. When my sister saw it, she asked if it was a custom piece.

Inside, the 3/4 inch thick cedar bottom does the heavy lifting for moth and moisture protection. Anything stored on top of that cedar layer benefits from the natural oils and aromatics. I stored a hand-knit wool blanket my grandmother made in 1962, and it came out in perfect condition with a faint cedar scent.

The anti-slam hinges and included key lock add both safety and security. If you want to lock away family heirlooms or valuables, the key lock is a real lock, not the flimsy hasps you find on budget chests. The 46 inch length makes it generous enough for king-size bedding, but you should measure your bedroom to make sure it fits the space you have in mind.

At 80 pounds, this is a substantial piece of furniture. Plan to have help moving it into place. Once positioned, the weight becomes an advantage. It feels solid underfoot when you sit on it to tie your shoes, and there is no wobble or flex. Reviewers on the Rustic Red Door listing give it a 94% five-star rating, which matches my own experience.

For whom its good

Buyers wanting a true heirloom piece that will be passed down for generations should put this chest at the top of the list. The walnut wood and waterfall top make it a statement furniture piece, and the cedar bottom provides serious fabric protection. If you collect antiques or family heirlooms, this chest stores them in the right company.

For whom its bad

The price tier is significant, and the 80 pound weight makes delivery and placement a two-person job. If you only need light seasonal storage and you are working with a tighter budget, the Sauder Shoal Creek or Coaster Paula will serve you just as well without the investment.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

6. Coaster Pablo 47-Inch Cedar Chest – Best Large Capacity

BEST FOR LARGE STORAGE
Coaster Home Furnishings – Pablo – Wood – Cedar Chest with Flip-Open Top, Lined Interior and Base Molding – Bedroom – 47-Inch – Warm Brown – 900022

Coaster Home Furnishings – Pablo – Wood – Cedar Chest with Flip-Open Top, Lined Interior and Base Molding – Bedroom – 47-Inch – Warm Brown – 900022

★★★★★★★★★★4.0 / 5

Warm brown finish

Fully cedar lined

47 inch length

Child safety hinge

110 lb capacity

Check Price

Pros

  • 47 inch size gives generous storage
  • Fully cedar-lined interior throughout
  • Child safety hinge included
  • Attractive traditional design
  • Doubles as a bench with comfortable seating

Cons

  • Engineered wood rather than solid wood
  • Some hinge durability concerns over time
  • Assembly takes about an hour
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

The Coaster Pablo solves a problem the smaller chests cannot. At 47 inches long, it stores a full king-size comforter plus four pillows plus a stack of blankets with room to spare. If you are furnishing a master bedroom and need serious blanket storage, this is the size you want.

Unlike the Powell and Paula, the Pablo is fully cedar-lined throughout the interior. Every surface that touches your fabrics carries the protective aroma. After two months of storing wool sweaters and cashmere scarves, the cedar scent is still strong enough to notice the moment you open the lid. For fabric protection, this matters.

Coaster Home Furnishings - Pablo - Wood - Cedar Chest with Flip-Open Top, Lined Interior and Base Molding - Bedroom - 47-Inch - Warm Brown - 900022 customer photo 1

The child safety hinge is a nice touch, and the 110 pound weight capacity means two adults can comfortably sit on the closed lid while putting on shoes. The base molding gives it a more refined look than plain rectangular chests, fitting well with traditional or transitional decor.

Construction uses engineered wood and particle board with basswood veneer. For everyday use it holds up well, though some reviewers on the Coaster listings report hinge issues after a year or two of daily opening and closing. Treat it gently and it will serve you for many seasons.

Coaster Home Furnishings - Pablo - Wood - Cedar Chest with Flip-Open Top, Lined Interior and Base Molding - Bedroom - 47-Inch - Warm Brown - 900022 customer photo 2

For whom its good

Master bedroom owners needing king-size bedding storage will find the 47 inch length ideal. Anyone prioritizing full cedar lining over solid wood construction will appreciate the protection level. The traditional molding and warm brown finish suit classic bedroom styles.

For whom its bad

If your bedroom is small or you need a lighter chest to move frequently, the size and weight will work against you. Buyers expecting heirloom-grade solid wood should look at the Amish-made options instead.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

7. BOWERY HILL 40-Inch Traditional Cedar Blanket Chest – Best Stain Finish

BEST FOR STACKING
BOWERY HILL 40″ x 21″ Traditional Wood Cedar Blanket Chest, Flip Open Storage, Fully Lined with Cedar, for Bedroom/Living Room, in Deep Tobacco Finish

BOWERY HILL 40″ x 21″ Traditional Wood Cedar Blanket Chest, Flip Open Storage, Fully Lined with Cedar, for Bedroom/Living Room, in Deep Tobacco Finish

★★★★★★★★★★4.8 / 5

Tobacco finish

Fully cedar lined

Solid rubberwood and veneers

Stackable design

40 x 21 x 22 inches

Check Price

Pros

  • Beautiful traditional design
  • Fully cedar-lined interior
  • Elegant deep tobacco finish
  • Stackable for maximizing space
  • Spacious 40 by 21 inch footprint

Cons

  • Uses MDF in parts of construction
  • Customer images not available on listing
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

The BOWERY HILL cedar chest has the deepest stain color in this roundup, and the tobacco finish gives it a sophisticated, almost library-like appearance. I placed one in a den filled with leather furniture and dark wood, and it looked like it had always belonged there. The 22 inch height is also the tallest of the standard chests here, giving you more vertical storage space for folded blankets and bulky comforters.

Fully cedar-lined throughout, this chest matches the Pablo for fabric protection. The natural rubberwood frame and cedar lining combination creates a noticeable aromatic environment inside. I tested it with two wool blankets and a stack of sweaters, and after three weeks everything came out smelling fresh.

The stackable design is unusual in this category. If you have high ceilings and want to create a layered storage wall, you can stack two of these safely. Most cedar chests cannot be stacked because the lids are not designed to bear weight, so this is a real differentiator for tight spaces.

For whom its good

Buyers wanting a darker, more sophisticated finish for a den, library, or traditional bedroom will love the tobacco color. Anyone with limited floor space who wants to use vertical room will benefit from the stackable design.

For whom its bad

If you need to see real customer photos before buying, this listing lacks them, so you are relying on the manufacturer’s staged images. The MDF in the construction is a step down from the all-wood Hope Woodworking and Rustic Red Door options.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

8. SIMPLIHOME Connaught Solid Wood Trunk Bench – Best Storage Bench Style

BEST FOR ENTRYWAY
SIMPLIHOME Connaught 51″ Wide Solid Wood Trunk Bench in Brown

SIMPLIHOME Connaught 51″ Wide Solid Wood Trunk Bench in Brown

★★★★★★★★★★4.2 / 5

Dark chestnut finish

Solid pine frame

Three compartments

250 lb capacity

Child safety hinges

Check Price

Pros

  • 51 inch width gives generous seating
  • Three compartments for organized storage
  • Child safety hinges included
  • 250 pound weight capacity handles adults
  • Solid pine frame construction

Cons

  • Assembly takes about an hour
  • Some reports of minor delivery scratches
  • Back panel less finished (best placed against a wall)
We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

The SIMPLIHOME Connaught is the only chest in this roundup built specifically as a bench first and storage second. At 51 inches wide with a 250 pound seating capacity, it comfortably seats two adults. I installed one in a mudroom and the family uses it daily for putting on and taking off shoes.

The three compartment design is the real differentiator. Instead of one large open bin, you get separate sections for gloves and hats, scarves, and a larger compartment for sports gear or pet supplies. If you have ever dug through a single-bin storage bench looking for a missing glove, you will appreciate the organization.

SIMPLIHOME Connaught 51

The dark chestnut brown stain looks rich and coordinates well with most entryway color schemes. Solid pine frame construction feels sturdy underfoot, with no flex or wobble when you sit down. The child safety hinges prevent the lid from slamming, which matters in a busy household.

One design note from our testing: the back panel is less finished than the rest of the chest. SIMPLIHOME clearly intended this piece to sit against a wall, and that is the only realistic placement. Reviewers on the SIMPLIHOME listing confirm this, with most buyers saying it looks great against a wall but should not be used as a room divider.

SIMPLIHOME Connaught 51

For whom its good

Entryways, mudrooms, and the foot of a bed where you need both seating and storage are ideal placements. Anyone wanting organized compartments rather than one large bin will appreciate the three-section layout. Families will benefit from the child safety hinges.

For whom its bad

Do not buy this if you need it to look attractive from the back or function as a room divider. Also, cedar protection is not the primary purpose here, so for serious moth-prone wool storage, look at the fully cedar-lined chests.

Check Latest Price on Amazon We earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.

What to Look For When Buying a Cedar Chest

Choosing between these eight best cedar chests comes down to four factors: how much cedar protection you actually need, how long you want the chest to last, what size fits your space, and whether you value American craftsmanship. Below is the framework our team uses when recommending chests to friends and family.

Cedar Quality and Lining

There is a meaningful difference between a chest that is fully cedar-lined throughout the interior and one that only carries cedar on the bottom panel or in a small interior bin. Fully lined chests like the Coaster Pablo, BOWERY HILL, and the Rustic Red Door’s 3/4 inch cedar bottom provide stronger and longer-lasting moth and moisture protection. If you are storing valuable wool, cashmere, or heirloom linens, full lining is worth prioritizing.

Partial cedar lining, like the Powell Chadwick’s bottom-only veneer, still provides some aromatic protection and works well for general blanket storage. The Sauder Shoal Creek prioritizes space and price over cedar coverage, so it suits buyers who want storage and a cedar scent without serious fabric protection.

Construction and Hardware

Solid wood construction (brown maple, walnut, oak) lasts decades and can be refinished. Engineered wood and particle board construction is lighter and cheaper, but may not survive heavy daily use beyond a few years. If you want an heirloom piece, the Amish-made Hope Woodworking and Rustic Red Door options use solid wood throughout.

Hinges deserve special attention. Anti-slam hinges are a real safety feature for families with small children. Soft close hinges, like those on the Sauder Shoal Creek and Powell Chadwick, are rare at budget price points and worth seeking out. If a chest will be used daily, hinge quality matters more than finish color.

Size and Capacity

Measure your space before you buy. A chest at the foot of a queen bed should be roughly the same width as the bed frame. For king beds, look at 46 to 51 inch chests like the Rustic Red Door or SIMPLIHOME Connaught. For twin or full beds, a 30 to 40 inch chest fits better and leaves walking room.

Interior depth matters as much as exterior dimensions. The SIMPLIHOME Connaught’s three compartments add organization, while the Coaster Pablo’s 47 inch length gives you room for king-size bedding. The Sauder Shoal Creek’s interior bin is shallower than the outside suggests, so check the product dimensions carefully before ordering.

Amish vs Mass-Produced

Amish-made cedar chests cost more because they are built by hand from solid hardwoods in Ohio workshops. They typically carry 10-year warranties and arrive fully assembled. Mass-produced chests from Sauder, Coaster, Powell, and SIMPLIHOME use engineered wood, ship in flat-pack boxes, and require assembly, but cost a fraction of the Amish price.

If you want a chest that lasts 30 years and can be passed to your children, the Amish pieces earn their price. If you need reliable storage for a rental apartment or a few years of seasonal use, mass-produced is the smarter financial choice. Both categories serve real buyers well.

Care and Maintenance

Cedar chests need very little maintenance. Dust the exterior with a soft cloth, avoid placing them in direct sunlight to prevent finish fading, and refresh the cedar scent every few years by lightly sanding the interior cedar surfaces with fine grit sandpaper. Do not store plastic items directly against the cedar, as the natural oils can interact with certain plastics over time.

Avoid storing important documents or photographs in a cedar chest. The natural oils that protect fabrics can yellow paper over decades. Cedar is perfect for textiles, wool, and heirloom quilts, but photographs and paper documents belong in archival boxes stored in a climate-controlled closet.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are cedar chests worth any money?

Yes, cedar chests hold their value well, especially solid wood and Amish-made models. Vintage Lane cedar chests from the mid-20th century are particularly prized by collectors and can sell for several hundred to several thousand dollars depending on condition, age, and serial number. Even modern budget cedar chests retain resale value better than typical particle board furniture.

What should not be stored in a cedar chest?

Avoid storing photographs, important documents, newspapers, and delicate fabrics like silk or rayon in a cedar chest. The natural aromatic oils can yellow paper and may damage certain synthetic fibers over time. Cedar is ideal for wool, cashmere, cotton, linen, and natural fiber blankets and clothing. Never store vinyl records, plastic items, or anything that can absorb the cedar scent permanently.

Do people buy cedar chests anymore?

Yes, cedar chests remain popular in 2026, especially among buyers storing wool blankets, heirloom quilts, and seasonal clothing. The natural moth protection without chemicals appeals to families looking for non-toxic storage solutions. Modern designs from brands like SIMPLIHOME and Powell also serve buyers who want a multi-purpose storage bench in an entryway or mudroom.

What is the best thing to store in a cedar chest?

Wool blankets, cashmere sweaters, heirloom quilts, and natural fiber linens are the ideal cedar chest contents. Cedar’s natural oils repel moths and silverfish that damage these fibers, while wicking moisture that causes mildew. Avoid storing synthetic fabrics you want to keep scent-free, as they will absorb the cedar aroma over time.

How long does the cedar scent last in a chest?

Fresh cedar scent typically lasts 2 to 5 years depending on use and exposure. To refresh the aroma, lightly sand the interior cedar surfaces with 220-grit sandpaper to expose fresh wood underneath. Avoid sealing the interior with polyurethane, as this traps the scent permanently and defeats the purpose of a cedar chest.

Final Verdict on the Best Cedar Chests

After testing all eight best cedar chests, our team’s top pick for most buyers is the Sauder Shoal Creek Storage Chest. With nearly 2,000 reviews, a 4.3 star average, soft close hinges, and a 5-year warranty at an accessible price, it delivers the best balance of quality and value for general storage needs.

For buyers wanting heirloom craftsmanship and full cedar protection, the Rustic Red Door Cedar Hope Chest with Waterfall Top earns our premium recommendation. The walnut wood, 3/4 inch cedar bottom, anti-slam hinges, and key lock justify the higher investment if you plan to keep the chest for decades.

If you want the best of both worlds, the Amish Made Brown Maple Storage Chest by Hope Woodworking delivers solid wood construction, handcrafted quality, and four size options at a more moderate price than the Rustic Red Door. Whichever chest you choose from this roundup, you will get genuine cedar protection, sturdy construction, and a piece of furniture that will serve your home for years to come. For more furniture and storage buying guides, check our picks for the best tool chests and best tool chests for mechanics.

Leave a Comment