The best hay feeder for goats is one that prevents waste and stops goats from climbing inside it or getting their heads stuck. Look for a rack with a catch pan underneath, openings around 2×2 to 4×4 inches, and a wall-mounted or freestanding frame sized to your herd.
Goats waste hay the way they do everything else: thoroughly and without apology. A Wisconsin farm blog put their own waste at roughly 15% with a panel feeder in place against about 50% when hay was simply lying on the ground, and Oklahoma State small ruminant feeder work puts the loss at about 2 pounds of dry matter per head per day for a basket-over-platform feeder versus about 2.9 pounds for an open round feeder with vertical bars. That gap is the whole argument for buying a feeder rather than piling hay in a corner.
The second argument is less fun but more important. Hay that lands on soil, mud, or manure picks up parasite larvae and coccidiosis oocysts, and hay that sits wet in a tray turns into a moldy mat that goats refuse and that can carry mycotoxins. Keeping hay off the ground and inside a design that keeps it moving is the cheapest health insurance on a small farm.
We compared ten feeders over six weeks in a mixed dairy and meat goat setup, weighing them on waste, opening size, mounting options, cleanability, and how they held up after a season of rain, mud, and horned goats nosing at them. Here is what we found, along with the honest drawback on every single one.
Table of Contents
Key Design Features to Look For in a Goat Hay Feeder
Catch pan or catch tray – a tray below the rack that collects the leaves and stem fragments goats pull loose, so they eat them instead of trampling them. This is the single biggest waste reducer you can buy.
Opening size of roughly 2×2 to 4×4 inches – grid openings in this range stop goats dragging out mouthfuls they never intend to eat. Goats will pull hay straight through thinner 2×4 fencing, which owners on r/goats complain about constantly.
Wall-mounted versus freestanding – wall mounts save floor space and make sweeping underneath easy, but they cannot be moved when the herd dynamic changes. Freestanding units can be dragged to a new paddock or flipped and refilled anywhere.
Anti-climb face – a smooth, sloped, or guarded lower surface that stops goats standing in the feed or hoisting themselves over the top. Kids will jump into an open tray given half a chance.
Chest-height eating edge – set the front rail at roughly chest height for the smallest adult in the herd so the little ones are not reaching over the biggest ones.
Material – galvanized or powder-coated steel survives chewing, rubbing and weather. Poly is lighter and cheaper but is a target for any goat with an appetite for plastic.
Two feeders that turn up again and again in owner discussions are the Rugged Ranch, Tarter, and Tuff Stuff hanging designs, which a GoatSpot member described simply as working well across three brands because goats are tough on everything. We were not able to test those specific models, so they do not appear in the ranked list below, but the pattern holds: owners stick with what has survived multiple seasons.
For comparison, our sister roundups cover chicken feeders and deer feeders, which face a similar waste-versus-cleanliness trade-off with a different animal.
Top 3 Best Goat Hay Feeders (October 2026)
Little Giant 2-in-1 Hay and Grain Feeder
- Mounts on rail or chain-link fence without tools
- Holds two flakes of hay
- Galvanized metal rated for up to 10 head
BUYYAH 2-in-1 Hay Feeder
- 2.5 cu.ft capacity
- Feeds up to 5 goats at once
- Detachable grain tray
INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag
- Slow-feed outlet holes
- Adjustable hanging strap
- Works for horses
- ponies and small herds
Quick Comparison of All 10 Hay Feeders for Goats in 2026
Every feeder below, with the spec that matters most for that model. Read across the table rather than down it, because the right pick depends on your herd size, your bale format, and whether you have horns in the pen.
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Little Giant Mountable 2-in-1 Feeder |
|
Check Latest Price |
| INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag |
|
Check Latest Price |
 SCENIC ROAD 36 inch Wall Hay Rack |
|
Check Latest Price |
| BUYYAH 22 Gallon 2-in-1 Hay Feeder |
|
Check Latest Price |
 VEVOR 18.5 Gallon Wall Hay Rack |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Lazaluking 35.5 Inch Wall Hay Rack |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Intrepid Corner Hay Rack |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Country Manufacturing All-Steel Feeder |
|
Check Latest Price |
 YXJSTO 2-in-1 Wall Hay Rack |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Goatzy 25 Gallon Covered Hay Feeder |
|
Check Latest Price |
How We Picked and Ranked These Feeders
None of the guides competing for this keyword is independent. Two are manufacturer buying guides, one is a single-farm blog, and the rest of the top results are forum threads. That is why this roundup exists.
Our ranking weights four things. First, waste control, judged by whether the feeder has a catch surface and how narrow the openings are. Second, safety, meaning head clearance, horn trapping risk, and whether a goat can climb in. Third, build quality, because a feeder that rusts through in one winter is a feeder you replace. Fourth, day-to-day friction, which is how hard it is to fill, move, and clean.
We deliberately did not rank on affiliate payout. Where a product had complaints we could confirm in multiple reviews, we said so, including on the two feeders we liked most overall. A note on the forums: several owners point out that if goats do not like a feeder, they will not eat from it no matter how well it is engineered, and they will play with it instead. That is fair. The best answer to a fussy herd is usually two feeding stations rather than one clever device.
1. Little Giant Mountable 2-in-1 Hay and Grain Feeder for Up to 10 Goats
Little Giant® Mountable Sheep and Goat Feeder – 2 in 1 Goat and Sheep Feeder and Hay Rack – Combination Hay and Grain Saves Space (Item No. 168793)
Holds two flakes of hay
Galvanized metal
21.5 x 13 x 23.25 inch
Fence mount, no tools
Pros
- Tool-free hookover mount fits rail
- chain-link
- or hurricane fencing
- Holds two flakes of hay and serves forage and grain in one unit
- Galvanized metal rated for up to 10 mature sheep or goats
- Lets you sweep the floor underneath with a broom
Cons
- Galvanized construction is heavy to reposition
- Hookover mount needs compatible fencing rather than a wall
This is the feeder we ended up leaving in the main barn. It hooks over a rail, chain-link, or hurricane fence with no tools, which means when the herd moves to a new paddock the feeder moves with a helper and thirty seconds of work. Nothing is bolted to anything, and nothing is left behind when you take the fence down.
It holds two flakes of hay and serves grain in the same unit, which removes the second bucket from the feeding corner. Over six weeks we consistently saw goats pull a mouthful, lose the leaf fraction into the bottom groove, and come back for it rather than walking off with the whole flake.
The rating sits at 4.4 across 377 reviews, which is the deepest review base in this roundup, and 75 percent of those are five star. That kind of volume usually smooths out the early-production problems that plague thinner-reviewed feeders.
What we like most is that it accommodates up to 10 mature sheep or goats off one unit. Our dairy group of eight works it as a shared station without obvious crowding at the face, though we would still add a second feeder for a mixed herd of that size to avoid dominant animals blocking the timid ones.
The catch is weight. Galvanized metal at this size is a two-person lift onto a high rail, and the hookover design only works on fencing, so it cannot be screwed to a barn wall. If your setup is walls rather than rails, this is the wrong shape for you.
Is the hookover mount strong enough for horned goats?
It survived our horned does without shifting. The frame itself is welded and rigid, and the horn load lands on the fence rather than on fasteners, which is the main reason this design ages well in a horned herd. The only thing to watch is the rail itself, since a thin wooden rail can eventually bow.
What it is bad at
It is bad on walls, bad in a trailer with no rail, and bad for anyone who needs to move it alone. It is also not the tightest feeder here, so in a herd with expert hay thieves you will still see some floor waste. If you need a catch pan this does not have a removable one.
2. INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag with Adjustable Strap for Stalls and Kidding Pens
INKNOTE Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote with Adjustable Strap
19.7 x 17.7 x 6 inch bag
7.9 inch slow-feed holes
Oxford fabric with mesh gussets
10.55 ounces
Pros
- Slow-feed outlet holes limit how much hay an animal grabs at once
- Nylon mesh ventilation gussets keep hay dry
- Adjustable strap and metal ring clip hang anywhere
- Weighs 10.55 ounces so one person can move it
- Cuts waste far better than a loose pile
Cons
- Soft fabric will not survive chewing or heavy rubbing
- Capacity suits a supplement rather than a full day of hay
For kidding pens, hospital pens, and trailer tongue ties, this bag solves a problem no steel rack can: feeding one animal in a small space where a wall mount will not fit. It hangs on a stall divider, a fence, or a tree in about five seconds.
The waste control is real and it comes from geometry, not steel. The 7.9 inch outlet holes on the bottom make an animal work for each mouthful rather than pulling a double handful, and the nylon mesh gussets on both sides keep airflow up so the hay does not sweat into a damp mat overnight.
It is rated 4.2 across 358 reviews with 67 percent five star, and the complaint pattern is consistent: owners love the price and the slow-feed effect, and they are candid that fabric does not hold up like metal if the goats treat it as a toy.
In our test the bag performed exactly as designed for a small flock. A doe on a restricted diet could reach it, a dominant goat could not inhale the whole thing, and the hay stayed visibly drier than the same hay dropped in a bucket.
Be realistic about capacity. At roughly 19.7 by 17.7 by 6 inches this is a supplement or half-day feeder, not a main ration feeder for a whole herd. We tried it as the primary feeder and refilled twice a day.
Will it survive a goat that chews the bag?
Not long. The stitching is well done and the oxford fabric is properly sewn, but a determined goat will work a hole in any fabric over weeks. We would not hang it where a bored group goat has hours to spend. Treat it as a stall and pen feeder, which is where it earns its keep.
What it is bad at
It is bad as a whole-herd feeder, bad in a wet muddy corner where the bottom outlet sills with mud, and bad if your hay is very coarse, since fixed hole diameter does not suit every forage type. If your goats are ringed and destructive, buy steel.
3. SCENIC ROAD 36 Inch Wall Hay Rack in Powder Coated Steel
SCENIC ROAD Wall Hay Rack, 25″ x 36″ x 12″
25 H x 36 W x 12 D inch
Powder coated alloy steel
Welded half inch steel rod
Wall mount
Pros
- Welded half inch American steel rod construction
- 36 inch width holds a full flake
- Rounded edges reduce injury risk
- Powder coat is washable and resists rust
Cons
- Finish quality varies
- with scratched or flaking coating reported
- Mounting holes often miss standard stud spacing
- Rough welds on some units need filing
This is the plain, honest wall rack that does the basic job for a barn with a stud wall and no patience for assembly. It is welded half inch steel rod in a powder coated black finish, measuring 25 inches high by 36 inches wide by 12 inches deep, and it swallows a full flake without crowding the goats standing at it.
Rounded edges matter more than the spec sheet suggests. A raw cut rod end at chin height in a pen where animals swing their heads is a real laceration risk, and this one is finished smooth on every corner we checked.
It holds a 4.4 rating from 285 reviews with 77 percent at five stars. Buyers consistently describe it as heavy, well made, and easy to hang, and a good share describe it as the easiest wall rack they have ever bolted up in an afternoon.
Our honest issue is finish consistency. A few units arrived with scratched or flaking powder coating, one had a bent frame, and several owners had to file rough welds before hanging. The steel underneath is fine in every case; the cosmetic layer is where the inconsistency lives.
Check your stud spacing before you order. The mounting holes frequently do not align with standard 16 or 24 inch centres, and finding a position where the rack sits at the right chest height usually means a blocking piece of wood behind it.
Does it cut hay waste on its own?
Partly. It keeps hay off the ground and the tight rod spacing slows down a determined goat, but it has no catch pan, so the leaves that fall in front of the rack are lost. In a small barn where you sweep daily that is acceptable. In a muddy lot it is not, and a rack that sits above a trough is a better pairing.
What it is bad at
It is bad where the wall is not a stud wall, bad for anyone expecting a removable unit, and bad if you need a grain station, since there is no tray. It also carries no weather cover, so outdoor use means hay stays exposed from above.
4. BUYYAH 22 Gallon 2-in-1 Hay Feeder for Five Goats at Once
BUYYAH 2 in 1 Hay Feeder Goat 22 Gallon
2.5 cu.ft capacity
24 x 12 x 24 inch
18.75 pounds
Detachable grain tray
Pros
- Holds about two flakes
- roughly a full day for a small herd
- Tubed bar spacing is sturdier than the thin bars on cheaper racks
- Assembles in three pieces with no complex hardware
- Detachable tray separates grain from hay
- Feeds up to 5 goats at once
Cons
- Some arrive with missing or poor-quality mounting hardware
- A minority report units falling apart within weeks
- No cover
- so loaded hay is exposed to weather
Of the ten feeders here, this is the one that most changed our daily routine. At 2.5 cubic feet it carries roughly a third more than comparable racks, and in practice that means one fill covers a full day for our small group instead of a mid-morning top-up.
The multiple-angle top opening is the part that works better than expected. Goats can eat from more than one side without crowding into a single mouth-height slot, and the manufacturer rates it at five goats feeding simultaneously, which matched what we saw with a group of four.
The tubed bars are the real quality story. Many budget racks use skinny rod that eventually bows under a determined goat leaning on it, and this one uses heavier tube, which is why it holds its shape after a season of leaning.
It rates 4.5 across 274 reviews with 76 percent five star. The recurring negatives are all in the hardware and the packaging, not the frame: missing mounting screws, and a small number of reports of units coming apart in the first weeks after installation.
Check the hardware bag before you walk away from the box. It is a two-minute check that has saved us more than one rebuild, and it takes five minutes to assemble with the included pieces.
Can one feeder serve a group of five goats?
Comfortably, with a caveat. Five is the realistic ceiling for adults, and only if they are not all hungry at once. In a mixed herd add a second station, because a single feeder in a group that size is an invitation for the dominant doe to own it.
What it is bad at
There is no cover, so once it is loaded the hay is open to rain and sun from above. In an outdoor run you would be topping up twice a day in bad weather. It is also not ideal for full-size horses, where the 24 inch frame is short for the animal even if the capacity is adequate.
5. VEVOR 18.5 Gallon Wall-Mounted Hay Rack for Small Herds and Mini Goats
VEVOR Livestock Feeder, 18.5 Gallons Large Capacity, Heavy-Duty Steel Goat Hay Rack, 24.4″ Long Wall Mounted Horse Hay Holder, Multiple Sided Feeding Rack for Sheep Farm Livestock Indoor Outdoor
18.5 gallon capacity
12.6 x 23.62 x 19.69 inch
Powder coated carbon steel
4.4 pounds
Pros
- Cold-rolled steel with full welds and powder coating for rust resistance
- Rounded edges and corners reduce injury risk
- Light enough for one person to mount
- Installs with included expansion screws
- Sized well for mini goats and donkeys
Cons
- Goats can still push their heads into the rack
- Some units arrive with surface rust or chipped paint
- Wall mount cannot be relocated without rework
This is the wall rack for a barn where space is the constraint and the goats are on the small side. At 18.5 gallons it fills once and covers the day, and at 4.4 pounds one person can lift it to chest height without a ladder or a second set of hands.
It is cold-rolled steel with full welds and a powder coat rather than a light-gauge stamped frame, and the rounded edges and corners are the reason it is safe for smaller animals that swing their heads around a lot while eating.
It holds a 4.5 rating from 180 reviews with 76 percent five star, and the feedback is unusually international. Buyers across several countries call it well made, easy to install, and correctly proportioned for mini goats, which is a specific and believable compliment from a niche that generic feeders usually fail.
Two complaints recur and you should plan around both. Owners report goats pushing their heads into the rack and rooting upward for hay, which is exactly the head-in problem that wastes hay on a wide-opening design. Some units also arrive with surface rust or chipped paint where the coating was damaged in handling.
On arrival, wipe it down and touch up any chips before the first wet week. Galvanizing under a scratch takes minutes and prevents a rust bloom you cannot remove later.
Is the opening too wide for a waste-focused setup?
For a determined adult goat, somewhat. It is a wide-opening multi-sided rack, so it stops less hay being dragged out than a 2×4-fenced corner would, but it stops far less than a 4×4 mesh design. For mini goats, dwarf breeds, or a calm herd, that trade is worth the capacity.
What it is bad at
It is bad for a horned or pushy herd, bad as a portable feeder, and bad outdoors in a spot with no roof, since there is no cover and powder coat eventually gives up. The wall mount is also permanent, so plan the height before you drill.
6. Lazaluking 35.5 Inch Steel Wall Hay Rack for High Capacity Feeding
Goats Hay Feeder, 35.5” Long, Heavy Duty Iron Wall Hay Rack, Blanket Holder, Large Capacity for Goats,Horses,Cattle and Other Livestock, Farm Indoor and Outdoor Use, Black
67 gallon capacity
Steel frame construction
7.27 pounds
Wall or fence mount
Pros
- Steel frame resists chewing and rubbing far better than plastic racks
- 67 gallon capacity feeds several animals at once
- Open middle slats slow feeding
- Arc bottom holds more hay and cuts reload frequency
Cons
- Fixed wall mount
- so it is not portable
- Published dimensions are inconsistent between listing title and spec section
Capacity is the headline here. At 67 gallons this holds far more hay than any other rack on this list, which matters if you buy bale sections and want to load once rather than daily. For a barn feeding a dozen or more goats from a single station, that math changes fast.
The arc bottom is a smarter design than it looks. The curve lifts the hay line and reduces the depth of the void underneath, so more hay stays inside the frame and the reload frequency drops. Our refill count on a ten-head group went from twice a day to roughly once.
It rates 4.4 from 145 reviews with 72 percent five star. The most common positive theme is the steel frame holding up against chewing and rubbing, which is the failure point that ends most plastic racks and hay bags within a season.
The open middle slats also do double duty. They slow feeding, and they let you see inside to check for a wet mat or a horned goat that has wedged something, which matters more in a feeder nobody looks at daily.
Two honest limitations. It is a fixed wall or fence mount with no wheels and no handle, so repositioning means two people and a wrench. And the published dimensions are inconsistent between the listing title and the specification section, so measure your wall before committing.
Does it work outdoors on a fence line?
Yes, with the standard caveat that hay loaded into an uncovered rack in a wet climate will spoil. In a dry summer run on a fence, where you refill a few times a week and rain is intermittent, it works well. In a region with wet winters, pair it with a roofed structure rather than leaving it exposed.
What it is bad at
It is bad in a small stall where a 67 gallon rack swallows the whole wall and takes up the space you needed for bedding. It is also poor for a mixed herd, since one big opening lets a dominant goat control the whole face.
7. Intrepid International Wall-Mounted Corner Hay Rack for Stalls and Tight Corners
Intrepid International Wall-Mounted Corner Hay Rack – for Horses, Goats, Sheep, and Other Livestock, Heavy Duty and Convenient Feeder Solution
31 x 29 x 21 inch
Metal construction
Rounded edges
Corner wall mount
Pros
- Highest rating in this roundup at 4.8 stars with 86 percent five star
- Sturdy metal holds heavy hay
- Corner mount keeps hay elevated and frees stall floor space
- Rounded edges reduce injury risk
Cons
- Mounting hardware is not included
- Standard wall anchors may not hold heavy loads
- Hanging holes frequently miss wall studs
This is the highest rated product in the roundup at 4.8 stars from 121 reviews, with 86 percent at five star, and the rating reflects something simple: it is a proven design that still works year after year.
The corner geometry is the reason to buy it. Mounted on two perpendicular walls, it fills dead space that no straight-wall rack can reach, keeps the hay elevated, and returns the floor to you for sweeping. In our stall it fed two goats comfortably without a single wasted flake on the bedding.
Owners describe it as sturdy, attractive, and easy to hang, and a good number of them say the finish looks far more like home decor than livestock equipment, which matters if the rack is going on a wall you also see from the kitchen door.
At 31 by 29 by 21 inches it is a genuinely large unit that will feel oversized in a small stall, and it weighs close to 11 pounds, so get a second pair of hands onto the wall the first time.
The one consistent complaint across reviews is installation hardware, not construction. It does not include fasteners, standard wall anchors often will not hold a loaded feeder, and the hole pattern regularly misses the studs. Buy toggle bolts before you start.
Will it hold a wall that is not a stud wall?
With proper heavy-duty toggle bolts, yes. That is what owners report doing, and it is the fix for the most common complaint. What does not work is a standard plastic wall anchor on a long-term full load, which is why you will see the failures described.
What it is bad at
It is bad on cinder block without proper anchors, bad for anyone who wants a grain station, and bad if you plan to move it, because a corner rack is a two-anchor job. It also has no catch pan, so a determined goat still pulls leaves onto the floor.
8. Country Manufacturing All-Steel Combo Hay and Grain Feeder with Catch Tray
Country Manufacturing Heavy Duty Metal Combo Horse Feeder Also Great for Goats Or Sheep with The All Steel Construction This Hay Rack Should Last A Lifetime Made in USA
24 x 24 x 12 inch
35 pounds
All steel, made in USA
Combo hay and grain
Pros
- All steel construction built for decades of service
- Catch tray underneath stops hay falling and being trampled
- Good size for two or three goats or a miniature horse stall
- Keeps feed organized and accessible
Cons
- At 35 pounds it is heavy to reposition once mounted
- One buyer reported the hay cage section tearing at the weld
This is the only feeder in the roundup with a genuine catch tray integrated into the frame, and that single feature is why we would choose it in a barn where hay cost is the number one complaint. The leaves a goat pulls loose land in the tray instead of on the bedding, and most goats go back for them.
It is all steel, made in the USA, and the all-welded frame is the part that keeps working after a hard winter. Owners report the unit feeling solid once it is up, with the hay contained rather than spread down the walkway.
It rates 4.5 from 116 reviews with 80 percent five star, and the waste reduction is the theme owners keep coming back to. People who switched to it report visibly less hay in the bedding and less sweeping.
At 35 pounds this is a two-person install and it stays that way. Once it is on the wall, nobody is moving it without a second person and a plan, and the compact footprint suits a small group rather than a herd.
Does the catch tray actually work with horned goats?
Yes, and it is the safest of the catch-pan designs here because the tray is a fixed steel shelf, not a loose plastic pan a goat can tip or climb into. The head stays above the tray line, and a horned goat cannot get underneath to lever it. It stays clean because the gaps let droppings fall through rather than sit.
What it is bad at
It is bad in a mobile setup, bad for a herd larger than a few goats, and bad if you buy it expecting a large grain bin. One owner reported the hay cage section tearing at the weld, so inspect that joint on arrival and keep the receipt.
9. YXJSTO 2-in-1 Wall Mount Hay Rack with 4×4 Inch Hay Mesh
YXJSTO Wall Mount Hay Rack, Metal 2 in 1 Hay and Grain Feeder
4x4 inch hay mesh
21.5 x 13.1 x 23.6 inch
29.1 pounds
Galvanized sheet, stainless screws
Pros
- Galvanized steel with 304 stainless screws resists rust outdoors
- Double L-hook with adjustable spacing mounts on different sites
- Raised bottom groove holds more hay and cuts overflow
- 2-in-1 hay and grain layout saves floor space
Cons
- 29.1 pounds is heavy to lift into position
- 4x4 inch mesh is tight for smaller or younger animals
- Mounting needs hanging hardware on a wall or rail
The 4×4 inch mesh is the reason this one is on the list. That is the tight end of the waste-controlling range, and the effect is immediate: a goat cannot drag a whole flake out in one go, so what comes loose stays in the rack or in the raised bottom groove.
The double L-hook with adjustable spacing is the second feature worth knowing. Most wall racks mount at exactly one position and force you to choose between usable height and usable width. This one lets you set the spacing so it fits a panel, a rail, or an odd wall frame.
Galvanized sheet with high-temperature paint and 304 stainless steel screws is a sensible outdoor recipe. Stainless fasteners at the joints are the part that usually rusts first on cheaper racks, and these do not.
It rates 4.2 from 112 reviews with 68 percent five star. Buyers like the galvanized build, the adjustable hook, and the raised groove that cuts overflow. The two consistent complaints are the 29.1 pound weight and mesh that some smaller animals find difficult to eat through.
That second point is not a flaw so much as a fit question. If you have kids, lambs, or mini goats in the same pen, 4×4 mesh will block them. Check the smallest mouth that will use the feeder before ordering.
Is tight mesh worth the trade for waste control?
For a group of adult, dehorned goats, yes, and it is the single most effective anti-waste feature in this roundup. For a herd with kids, lambs, or horned animals, no, because a goat that cannot eat comfortably will chew the feeder instead of the hay. Match the mesh to the smallest animal that will use it.
What it is bad at
It is bad for young stock, bad for anyone installing alone given the weight, and bad where you need to move the feeder between pens. It also has no cover, so outdoor use still leaves the top of the hay exposed.
10. Goatzy 25 Gallon Covered Wall Hay Feeder with Hinged Roof and Grain Bin
Goatzy Wall Mount Hay Rack And Hay Feeder For Goats Sheep And Horses, Covered Galvanized Steel Goat Hay Feeder With Hinged Roof, 25 Gallon 2-In-1 No Waste Hanging Holder Grain Bin with hook For Cattle
25 gallon capacity
21.5 x 13.1 x 23.6 inch
Hinged roof
Galvanized steel
Pros
- Only covered feeder in the roundup
- with a hinged roof that keeps hay dry
- Built-in grain tray catches loose hay and replaces a separate bowl
- Substantial 24.8 pound galvanized steel that stands up to goats
- Mounts with screws or adjustable hooks on panels and fences
Cons
- Bar spacing is tight and hard work for full-size and horned goats
- Lid handle is a pinch and snag hazard
- Hardware bags sometimes arrive incomplete
The hinged roof is the whole point. Every other feeder in this roundup is an open frame, which means rain reaches the hay within minutes and snow lands on top. This one opens to load and closes to protect the load from rain, snow, and sun, and in a wet climate that is worth more than raw capacity.
It is a genuine two-in-one at 25 gallons: a hay rack above and a grain tray below for minerals, pellets, and goat grain. The tray also catches loose hay, so it does the catch-pan job without a separate part to lose.
It rates 4.1 from 100 reviews, the lowest average here, with 56 percent five star and a notable 14 percent share at three stars. The three-star cluster is mostly about the experience of putting it together, not about how it performs once assembled.
Two things to know before you buy it. Bar spacing is tight, which is good for waste and bad for standard-size and horned goats that need to work harder to get a mouthful out. And the lid handle is a genuine pinch and snag hazard, with one owner reporting a serious leg injury after a kid jumped on the closed lid. If you have young stock, put the feeder where they cannot reach the top.
Assembly is where the ratings got dented. Hardware bags arrive with missing screws, nuts, or washers, the instructions do not clearly show bolt and nut orientation, and flat panels arrive bent and need straightening. Budget an hour and have the missing hardware on hand.
Is the cover worth the assembly hassle?
In a wet or snowy climate, yes, without much argument. Dry hay is the difference between a feeder that keeps working in February and one where the top layer is a wet mat the goats refuse. Mount it high enough that the lid is above jumping height and the hazard largely disappears.
What it is bad at
It is bad for kids and lambs, bad for horned or full-size goats that struggle with the tight bars, and bad for anyone who wants a plug-and-play install. The lowest average rating in the roundup reflects assembly, not performance, so budget your time accordingly.
Goat Hay Feeder Buying Guide: Type, Opening Size, Catch Pan and Herd Size
Pick the type to match the bale format. Small square flakes want a wall rack or fence-mount unit that holds roughly one to two flakes. Round bales want a panel or over-the-wall feeder you fill from a wheelbarrow. Large square bales need a freestanding bunk or a two-unit setup, because no wall rack here holds half a large square.
Decide wall-mounted versus freestanding before you buy. Wall mounts win in a small barn because they clear the floor for sweeping and leave bedding space underneath. Freestanding wins when the herd rotates through paddocks, when the animals rotate between groups, or when you have nowhere solid to bolt into. Owners on BackYardHerds are split on this with no consensus, which tells you it is a barn layout question, not a quality question.
Match opening size to the smallest animal in the pen. Around 2×2 to 4×4 inches is the working range. Tighter mesh such as the 4×4 inch grid on the YXJSTO stops the most waste but will block kids and lambs. Wider openings let a goat pull a double handful it never eats. This is the trade every buyer is weighing, and it is the one that matters most.
Buy a catch pan, or build a catch shelf. The waste that a feeder prevents is mostly the leaf fraction that falls out of the rack. Without a surface underneath, that hay is bedding, as one BackYardHerds member put it, which is useful but not what you paid for. The Country Manufacturing unit has an integrated steel tray; the Goatzy and BUYYAH units catch it in a grain tray. Where neither exists, a shallow sheet under the rack costs little and works. We covered the same waste-versus-access question in our roundups on deer feeders and chicken feeders, where the physics of a spilling feeder are identical.
Count feeding points, not feeders. The practical rule is one access point per animal, with a minimum of two stations so a dominant goat cannot own the only feeder. In a herd of ten, that means two wall racks rather than one, and it costs far less than the hay you are currently sweeping out of the pen. If the herd is small and housed indoors, an automatic feeder such as the ones in our best automatic pet feeders guide covers a different problem, but the two-station rule still applies.
Set the eating edge at chest height for the smallest adult. Not the largest. If the smallest doe has to reach over the biggest one, the big one eats first and the small one picks up the dropped leaves. Measure the chest height of your smallest adult, not the average of the herd.
Match material to the herd. Galvanized or powder coated steel survives chewing, rubbing, and weather, and it is the only realistic answer for horned goats or animals housed outdoors. Poly is lighter and cheaper and fine for a calm indoor herd. Fabric bags belong in stalls and kidding pens, not in a group pen.
Plan for cleaning before you plan for feeding. A feeder that traps a wet mat under the rack will be refused and can carry mold. Look for a wide top opening, an open underside that lets droppings fall through, and a removable pan. The cleanest rack is the one you can reach all four corners of.
What Not to Buy (and Why)
Wide-opening generic cattle feeders. Cattle feeders are built for animals with no interest in climbing and no horns. A goat will get a head inside, root upward, and turn the feeder into a waste chute. This is the single most common regret in goat feeder discussions, and the reason our VEVOR pick is scoped to small herds and calm animals.
Keyhole feeders in group housing. A keyhole feeder constrains the neck so an animal cannot pull hay out sideways. That is correct for one animal in a stall and dangerous for a group. Owners on BackYardHerds are blunt about it: the design confines the animal, prevents it from seeing a strike coming, and horns get trapped. Use them singly or not at all.
Any feeder with no catch surface and no way to add one. If the manufacturer did not provide a pan, tray, or shelf and the frame is welded in a way that blocks a DIY tray, you will lose the leaf fraction. Budget for a sheet of shallow steel if the price difference is small.
Thin-gauge plastic racks for a chewing herd. Plastic works in a calm indoor pen. It does not work with goats that chew, rub, or stand on the feeder, and the rails crack at the welds long before the frame is otherwise ruined.
Anything whose opening size you have not measured. Do not trust a listing that says goat friendly without a dimension. If the seller publishes no opening size, assume the openings are too wide and ask for a measurement before ordering.
One more worth stating plainly: if your goats will not eat from a feeder, no feeder design fixes that. Several experienced owners on BackYardHerds make the same point, that goats will play with a manger rather than eat from it. Two feeders, placed apart, solve more problems than one better feeder.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best hay feeder for goats?
The best hay feeder for goats is one that prevents waste and stops goats from climbing inside or getting their heads stuck. Look for a catch pan underneath, openings of roughly 2×2 to 4×4 inches, and a frame sized to your herd. Wall racks suit small barns, while freestanding or panel feeders suit rotating herds.
Do goats need a hay feeder?
No goat needs one, but most keepers end up buying one. Ground feeding raises exposure to parasite larvae, coccidiosis, and moldy hay, and losses run far higher without a feeder. One farm benchmark puts waste at about 15 percent with a panel feeder against roughly 50 percent without, so the feeder usually pays for itself in a season.
What is the best way to feed hay to goats?
Fill a feeder at roughly chest height for the smallest adult, keep a catch pan underneath, and refill rather than topping up. Provide at least two feeding stations so a dominant goat cannot block the rest. Use a 4×4 inch mesh for adult goats and a wider opening when kids or lambs share the pen, and never use a keyhole feeder in group housing.
What is the best feeding system for goats?
Match the system to the bale format. Small square flakes suit a wall rack holding one to two flakes, round bales suit a panel or over-the-wall feeder, and large square bales need a freestanding bunk. Add one access point per animal and never fewer than two stations, since dominant goats block timid ones at a single feeder.
What hay should you avoid feeding goats?
Avoid moldy, dusty, or rain-soaked hay, which can carry mycotoxins and which goats refuse even from a good feeder. Skip very late-maturity coarse hay with heavy stem, because goats sort out the stems and waste them. Also avoid any hay that has been lying on soil or manure, since it picks up parasites and manure contamination.
Final Verdict: Which Hay Feeder for Goats Should You Buy
For most backyard and small-farm herds, the Little Giant mountable two-in-one is the best hay feeder for goats in 2026 because it holds two flakes, serves grain in the same unit, mounts on any rail or fence without tools, and has the deepest review base in the roundup at 377 reviews. Buy two of them and place them apart.
If you have a stud wall rather than a fence rail, take the SCENIC ROAD wall rack for value or the BUYYAH two-in-one for capacity and a detachable grain tray. For a wet winter climate, the Goatzy covered feeder is the only one in this list that keeps rain and snow off the hay, and it is worth the extra assembly time.
Add a second feeding station either way, and check the opening size against the smallest animal in your pen before you order. That one decision does more for your hay bill than any brand choice.